Why Aluminum Foil Has a Dull Side and a Shiny Side - Reynolds Aluminum Foil Wrap

Consider the mystery solved.
According to Reynold's Kitchen, the difference between the two sides of aluminum foil is just a result of manufacturing.

Why is only 1 side of aluminum foil shiny?

Is There a Difference Between Tin Foil and Aluminum Foil? – LifeSavvy

Why Aluminum Foil Has a Dull Side and a Shiny Side - Reynolds Aluminum Foil Wrap

The Difference Between Aluminum and Tin Foil

People are just realising what you should use each side of tin foil for

Which side of foil should we cook on? - Quora

Eric Akis: How to use and recycle aluminum foil - Victoria Times Colonist

What You Should Know About Aluminum Foil

Is there a right side on aluminum foil

My aluminum foil shows which side is the nonstick side. : r/mildlyinteresting

Can Aluminum Foil Go In The Oven?

Should You Use Aluminum Foil With The Shiny Side Up Or Down?